Project

Back to overview

Family Building at Advanced Parental Age: An Interdisciplinary Approach

English title Family Building at Advanced Parental Age: An Interdisciplinary Approach
Applicant Wangmo Tenzin
Number 197415
Funding scheme Project funding
Research institution Institut für Bio- und Medizinethik (IBMB) Universität Basel
Institution of higher education University of Basel - BS
Main discipline Philosophy
Start/End 01.09.2021 - 31.08.2025
Approved amount 522'841.00
Show all

All Disciplines (2)

Discipline
Philosophy
Gynaecology

Keywords (8)

reproductive autonomy; sexism; medical ethics; Advanced parental age; welfare of the child; assisted reproductive technologies; social egg freezing; ageism

Lay Summary (German)

Lead
Die Gründung einer Familie im fortgeschrittenen Lebensalter stellt ein zunehmend verbreitetes Phänomen dar. Durch das höhere Alter der Eltern ergeben sich ethische Herausforderungen, die einer interdisziplinären Betrachtung bedürfen.
Lay summary
Das Projekt adressiert normative Themen, die bei Elternschaft im fortgeschrittenen Alter entscheidend sind. Hierzu zählen reproduktive Autonomie, Rechte und Pflichten der Eltern, Diskriminierung aufgrund von Geschlecht und Alter sowie das Wohl des Kindes. In diesem Spannungsfeld will das Projekt einen Rahmen für verantwortliche Elternschaft jenseits des 40. Lebensjahres entwickeln, und zwar in fünf Schritten. Zunächst wird die vorhandene normative Literatur auf relevante Argumente und Theorien hin überprüft, ehe zweitens bisherige empirische Untersuchungen zum Thema zusammengefasst und diskutiert. Drittens wird der regulatorische Rahmen der Schweiz mit demjenigen Belgiens verglichen, um exemplarisch den Einfluss von Gesetzen und Richtlinien auf die gelebte Praxis aufzuzeigen. Viertens erfasst eine qualitative Interviewstudie die Erfahrungen und Ansichten der beteiligten Personengruppen, ehe schliesslich in einem fünften Schritt empirische Befunde und normative Theoriebildung zu einem kohärenten normativen Rahmen für verantwortliche Elternschaft im fortgeschrittenen Alter vereint werden.

Im Sinne kritisch angewandter Ethik integriert das Projekt empirische und normative Herangehensweisen, um eine informierte Antwort auf Fragen nach der „guten“ Elternschaft im fortgeschrittenen Lebensalter zu geben. Damit leistet es einen Beitrag zur Forschung und bietet Hilfestellung bei der Entwicklung von praktischen Empfehlungen für Gesundheitswesen und Politik.
Direct link to Lay Summary Last update: 15.12.2020

Responsible applicant and co-applicants

Employees

Project partner

Abstract

Families with parents of Advanced Parental Age (APA) are becoming more and more common; a trend that has raised serious concerns for several reasons. APA is typically advised against as it is assumed that older parents will not be able to fulfil their parental duties. Older parenthood is associated with medical complications for the mother and for the child and an increase in the use of medical assistance to conceive. The debate on APA has focussed on a number of different topics including reproductive autonomy, parental rights and responsibilities, (discrimination on the basis of) gender and age, justice, and the welfare of the child. However, key principles, such as principle of reproductive autonomy (the right of a person to decide for her or himself when, how, etc. (s)he plans to reproduce) and the welfare of the child (which is the main argument used to restrict parental autonomy in reproduction) will need to be balanced against other values and must be understood in a setting of normative ideas. While more and more data are gathered on factors that contribute to the increase in parental age at first birth, little research is done on how society reacts (and should react) to this evolution and how citizens think about it. Our research aims to increase insight into how and why people decide to have children later in life and to what extent moral views and principles play a role in this decision and on how and why professionals make treatment decisions. Given the fact that every society has an elaborate set of rules and theories on family building and reproduction, it is important to explore whether personal views of citizens match this set and if not, in which direction changes should be made.The overall goal of the project is to create a strong and coherent normative framework about responsible family building at an advanced age: >40 years old for at least one of the parents. This normative framework, that is empirically informed, will help to design recommendations for clinical practice and policy making. To examine how age is used as a factor in decisions and moral reasoning about reproduction in two contexts: natural conception and reproductive medicine, we will critically analyse the validity and acceptability of widely accepted ethical principles and guidelines as well as the stakeholders’ convictions. The study will examine what defines a ‘good’ parent, which characteristics describe such a ‘good’ parent; and what are the minimal standards for parental competence. Special attention will be given to questions of justice and the presence of double moral standards in restrictions on women’s and men’s possibilities to procreate at an older age.This complementary study includes 1) an explorative study of the normative literature to scrutinize the principles, arguments and background theories forwarded and available in the academic and societal discussions on APA; 2) a critical analysis of existing empirical evidence delineating the extent to which parental age is a factor in relevant concerns resulting in arguments for and against APA in the two contexts; 3) a mapping of the regulatory framework on APA in Belgium and Switzerland to underscore how the law, regulations and guidelines shape the practice; 4) a qualitative interview study capturing the experiences of stakeholders and their moral views concerning responsible parenthood in relation to APA; and 5) an integration of the empirical findings and the normative-theoretical knowledge in a new and coherent normative framework about responsible family building at APA. Based on our combined expertise and disciplinary backgrounds and with the support of the partners of the research project, we will cover a multi-faceted research question in a way that creates new pathways of impact. The project will result in novel findings and important scientific outputs for the fields of reproductive medicine and biomedical ethics.
-