## Contact

Swiss National Science Foundation (SNSF)

Wildhainweg 3P.O. Box

CH-3001 Bern

Phone +41 31 308 22 22

English title | Credal Model Averaging for dealing with uncertainty in environmental models |
---|---|

Applicant | Rizzoli Andrea Emilio |

Number | 118071 |

Funding scheme | Project funding (Div. I-III) |

Research institution | Istituto Dalle Molle di studi sull’Intelligenza Artificiale (IDSIA) IDSIA USI-SUPSI |

Institution of higher education | University of Applied Sciences and Arts of Southern Switzerland - SUPSI |

Main discipline | Mathematics |

Start/End | 01.10.2008 - 30.09.2010 |

Approved amount | 93'975.00 |

Discipline |
---|

Mathematics |

Other disciplines of Environmental Sciences |

environmental model uncertainty; environmental model sensitivity; artificial intelligence; imprecise probabilities; model averaging

Lead |
---|

Lay summary |

In this project we address the problem of dealing with uncertainty in models of environmental systems. Such systems are often described by complex sets of equations, which tend to be overparametrised. Different models can therefore be calibrated to describe the same phenomenon and the model parameters display a complex interaction structure. A well-founded statistical framework to deal with model uncertainty is Bayesian model averaging (BMA), which prescribes to statistically aggregate the predictions issued by a set of several models, rather than relying on a single model. Yet, an open problem of BMA is how to set the prior distribution, which represents our beliefs about the models. A methodological solution to this problem would require to model prior ignorance, i.e., to regard as feasible all the priors that satisfy some general conditions, rather than ask the investigator to specify a unique, precise prior distribution. To this purpose, we propose to develop CMA (credal model averaging), i.e., to extend BMA to imprecise probabilities (or credal sets). CMA will output a set of posterior distributions (derived from the set or priors) for the variable of interest, rather than a single posterior distribution (derived from a single prior) as in BMA. The developed methodology will be validated by two applications, where model uncertainty plays a key role and nevertheless only little work has been done using BMA. The first one regards epidemiological studies of time series of air pollution and human health; US and European studies report indeed a difference of as much as 50-100% in the estimated air pollution effects, depending on the modelling approach adopted, and point out that there is no valid rule to choose from among them. The second application regards demographic models of animal populations; they are typically characterized by small data sets (for instance, 20 data). Usually, a single model is chosen to issue the predictions; moreover, its structure is also deeply analyzed, in order to point out how the different factors affect the population dynamics. In this case, not accounting for model uncertainty might lead to sub-optimal predictions, and also to unsafe conclusions about the population regulation. |

Direct link to Lay Summary | Last update: 21.02.2013 |

Name | Institute |
---|

Name | Institute |
---|

Number | Title | Start | Funding scheme |
---|

134759 | Credal networks made easy | 01.04.2011 | Project funding (Div. I-III) |

137680 | Learning under near-ignorance: models and methods | 01.01.2012 | Project funding (Div. I-III) |

146606 | Robust structure learning of Bayesian networks | 01.01.2014 | Project funding (Div. I-III) |

132252 | Multi Model Inference for dealing with uncertainty in environmental models | 01.10.2010 | Project funding (Div. I-III) |

In this proposal we want to address the problem of dealing with uncertainty in models of environmental systems. Such systems are often modelled by complex sets of equations, which tend to be overparametrised. Different models can therefore be calibrated to describe the same phenomenon and the model parameters display a complex interaction structure.A well-founded statistical framework to deal with model uncertainty is Bayesian model averaging (BMA), which prescribes to statistically aggregate the predictions issued by a set of several models, rather than relying on a single model. Yet, an open problem of BMA is how to set the prior distribution, which represents our beliefs about the models. A methodological solution to this problem would require to model prior ignorance, i.e., to regard as feasible all the priors that satisfy some general conditions, rather than ask the investigator to specify a unique, precise prior distribution. To this purpose, we propose to develop CMA (credal model averaging), i.e., to extend BMA to imprecise probabilities (or credal sets). CMA will output a set of posterior distributions (derived from the set or priors) for the variable of interest, rather than a single posterior distribution (derived from a single prior) as in BMA.The developed methodology will be validated by two applications, where model uncertainty plays a key role and nevertheless only little work has been done using BMA. The first one regards epidemiological studies of time series of air pollution and human health; US and European studies report indeed a difference of as much as 50-100% in the estimated air pollution effects, depending on the modelling approach adopted, and point out that there is no valid rule to choose from among them.The second application regards demographic models of animal populations; they are typically characterized by small data sets (for instance, 20 data). Usually, a single model is chosen to issue the predictions; moreover, its structure is also deeply analyzed, in order to point out how the different factors affect the population dynamics. In this case, not accounting for model uncertainty might lead to sub-optimal predictions, and also to unsafe conclusions about the population regulation.

Swiss National Science Foundation (SNSF)

Wildhainweg 3P.O. Box

CH-3001 Bern

Phone +41 31 308 22 22

Enter and manage your applications

Receive the latest news from us regularly with the SNSF Newsletter.

Continue© SNSF 2021