Project

Back to overview

Parcours des femmes ayant eu une interruption de grossesse dans le cadre des nouvelles dispositions du Code pénal suisse (art.119-120 CP, 02.06.2002) en Suisse romande

Applicant Perrin Eliane
Number 108465
Funding scheme DORE project funding
Research institution Haute Ecole de Santé de Genève (HEdS) HES-SO
Institution of higher education University of Applied Sciences and Arts Western Switzerland - HES-SO
Main discipline Health
Start/End 01.05.2005 - 31.05.2009
Approved amount 204'456.00
Show all

Keywords (10)

law; Abortion; women; healthcare professionnal; social workers; Abortion; law; healthcare professionnal; social workers; women

Lay Summary (English)

Lead
Lay summary

BACKGROUND: In 2002, by popular vote, Swiss citizens accepted to legalise termination of pregnancy (TOP), up to the 12th week of amenorrhoea (WA). As a result, the cantons formulated rules of application. In 2002, medical TOP was authorised. Health institutions then had to modify their procedures and practices.

QUESTIONS: One of the objectives of these changes was to simplify the clinical course for women who decide to terminate a pregnancy. Have the various health institutions in French-speaking Switzerland attained this goal? Are there differences between cantons? Are there any other differences, and if so, which ones? What are the views of healthcare professionals on the modifications of procedures and practices implemented in French-speaking Switzerland?

METHODS: Quantitative and qualitative method. Comparative study of cantonal rules of implementation. Study by questionnaire with 281 women having undergone a TOP. In-depth interviews with 77 healthcare professionals (doctors, nurses, midwives sexual and reproductive health social workers). Thematic analysis with content analysis software.

RESULTS: The comparative legal study of the six cantonal rules of implementation showed differences between cantons. The clinical course for women are defined by four quantifiable facts: 1) the number of days to wait between the woman’s decision (first step) and TOP; 2) the number of appointments attended before TOP; 3) the method of TOP; 4) the cost of TOP. On average, the waiting time was 12 days and the number of appointments was 3. The average cost of TOP was 1360 CHF. The differences, sometimes quite large, are explained by the size of the institutions (large university hospitals; average-sized, non-university hospitals; private doctors’ offices). Most professionals have a balanced point of view on their practices. There is no point of view specific to each different category of professionals interviewed. They are unanimous on the elimination of the need for a second opinion. The points of view diverge on the usefulness of imposed waiting time to think before TOP, minors’ access to TOP without parental consent, access to medical TOP

and the right to refuse to practice TOP for personal reasons in public hospitals.

CONCLUSIONS: The cantonal rules of implementation and the size of the health care institutions play an important role in women’s courses. The professionals do not question women’s right to have TOP up to 12 WA, but they do diverge over procedures and practices. Institutional and cantonal cultures are probably behind these differences.

Key words: termination of pregnancy; law reform; time span; women’s clinical course; medical costs; gynaecologists; healthcare professionals; medical abortion; conscientious refusal

Direct link to Lay Summary Last update: 21.02.2013

Responsible applicant and co-applicants

Employees

Project partner

Publications

Publication
Views of healthcare professionals dealing with legal termination of pregnancy up to 12 WA in French-speaking Switzerland
Perrin E, Berthoud M, Pott M, Vera AGT, Bianchi-Demicheli F (2012), Views of healthcare professionals dealing with legal termination of pregnancy up to 12 WA in French-speaking Switzerland, in SWISS MEDICAL WEEKLY, 1-7.
Clinical course in women undergoing termination of pregnancy within the legal time limit in French-speaking Switzerland
Perrin Eliane (2011), Clinical course in women undergoing termination of pregnancy within the legal time limit in French-speaking Switzerland, in Swiss Medical Weekly, 1-7.

-